Skip to content
    The Laws of Existence
    All cases
    U.S. District Court (D. Minn.) · U.S. Court of Appeals (8th Cir.)

    Kirchner v. Ellison

    Nos. 0:26-cv-00726 · 26-1615 · 0:26-cv-02594 · 90 documents on this site

    A pro se petition against Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison concerning state enforcement obligations under the federal constitutional framework. The matter spans three proceedings: the original action (dismissed), an Eighth Circuit appeal (summarily affirmed), and a refiled action carrying the substantive state-law claims forward in the District of Minnesota.

    Refiled action No. 0:26-cv-02594 dismissed August 20, 2026; appeal No. 26-1615 summarily affirmed June 25, 2026

    The refiled action was dismissed on August 20, 2026, and judgment entered the same day; the clerk’s notice of appeal time limits accompanies the judgment (Doc. 28-1).

    Latest filing: cv-02594 — Judgment in a Civil Case (Doc 28) · 2026-08-20

    The proceedings
    Original action

    No. 0:26-cv-00726

    U.S. District Court, D. Minn.
    Hon. Patrick J. Schiltz, Chief Judge

    Closed — amended complaint dismissed; judgment entered Mar 31, 2026

    1. Jan 27, 2026

      Petition and three memoranda of law filed

    2. Jan 28, 2026

      Summons issued

    3. Jan 29, 2026

      Emergency motion for TRO and declaratory relief

    4. Feb 23, 2026

      Proceedings stayed; motion-to-dismiss schedule set

    5. Mar 9, 2026

      Defendant’s motion to dismiss

    6. Mar 27, 2026

      Amended Complaint filed

    7. Mar 30, 2026

      Amended complaint dismissed; pending motions denied as moot

    8. Mar 31, 2026

      Judgment entered

    9. Apr 1, 2026

      Notice of appeal filed

    Eighth Circuit appeal

    No. 26-1615

    U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit
    Before Erickson, Grasz, and Kobes, Circuit Judges

    Decided — judgment summarily affirmed Jun 25, 2026 (8th Cir. R. 47A(a))

    1. Apr 2, 2026

      Appeal docketed

    2. May 12, 2026

      Opening brief filed — procedural issues only

    3. May 18, 2026

      Notice of the refiled district-court action

    4. Jun 25, 2026

      Judgment of the district court summarily affirmed

    Refiled action

    No. 0:26-cv-02594

    U.S. District Court, D. Minn.
    Hon. Laura M. Provinzino

    Closed — motion to dismiss granted; complaint dismissed; judgment entered Aug 20, 2026

    1. May 12, 2026

      Complaint filed — the substantive Chapter 8 state-law claims, refiled as a standalone action

    2. May 14, 2026

      Judge Bryan recuses; case reassigned to Judge Provinzino

    3. Jun 17, 2026

      Defendant’s motion to dismiss — to be heard on the papers

    4. Jul 8, 2026

      Plaintiff’s opposition filed

    5. Jul 23–24, 2026

      Defendant’s reply memoranda filed

    6. Jul 24–28, 2026

      Plaintiff moves for leave to file a surreply; Defendant opposes

    7. Aug 20, 2026

      Motion to dismiss granted; complaint dismissed; judgment entered